HomeMy WebLinkAbout1985-10-28 85-374 ORDER�1 85-3]4
Introduced by Councilor Cox, ectober 28, 1985
CITY OF BANGOR
(TIIlE.) &Ur Appeal from Decision of Historic Preservation
Commission: Fransway Realty
Company
- Property
at
169
Union
Street
By W-0ily6osMid<fb>f�8�f �artgori
-
WHEREAS, on August 29, 1985 Fransway Realty Company filed a
Application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for the construction
of an addition to the building located at 169 Union Street, Bangor,'
Maine, a copy of said Application being on file in the office of the
City Clerk; and
WHEREAS, on September 23, 1985, after hearing,. the Historic
Preservation Commission rejected said Application; and
WHEREAS, on October 16, 1985, Fransway Realty Company appealed
said decision of the Historic Preservation Commission to the Bangor
City Council pursuant to Chapter VII, Article 4, Section 10.5 of the
Ordinances of the City of Bangor,
HOW, THEREFORE, By the City Council of the City of Bangor:
ORDERED THAT, in accordance with Chapter VII, Article 4, Section
10.5 of the Ordinances of the City of Bangor, the decision of the
Historic Preservation Commission, dated September 23, 1985, to reject
an Application for a Certificate of Appropriateness by Fransway Realty
Company to construct a 2,390 square foot addition to the east side of
the existing structure located at 169 Union Street, Bangor, is hereby
(affirmed) (reversed)Imodified as follows: -
85-374
ORDER
IN CITY COUNCIL
Cetober 26, 1985 Title,
Referred to Nincrio Preservation
conmuttee - Consider next Meeting.
% Appeal from DeC........ of Histcric
........
..............................
a
a9A� i- ..P�.
.� CITY 'LEPK Frana
............pressuvatim ... ........ ...... ay Realty
Conq,any - Property at 169 Union Street
f9�
In City Council November
25,1985
In City Council November 13,1905 - resona{de"non: "seed
sound by deletSvg .reversed 8. In4orwl:
nd filed by m7. C Tier Me Grthy -
Modified as follows - Gnfl c't Vote 5 Yes ,3N0
vote b yes k no 1 abstained .. ...... .......... Aby edbio'.m,
voting yes Brom, CoNlebwlte, Councilman musing
Tilley Voting No Frenke1,9u111ven, ¢N C II Lebowitz, -Sullivan, Tilley
theele'e,Willey Abstaining Me Canny November 30, 1985 Voting No erankel,Whaeler,
Amended by deleting '4 exceed" Willey Abstaining ,
Amevdr yy deleting AffixieL'&'ModSPied and adding "affixmad" passed by Me Grthy
as follows the councilors
following yes es Votes. Vote in favor of Chairman
ewncaam voting yes: e[wn, cox, Rebwilu in reference to /(of
Vote g yes 4 no a Abstained days
Voting yes Frankel Sullivan Sullivan and ler ay.nd Willey.
Councilors Voting n for reconsideration
Wheeler,Willey Voting No Frankel, wheeler and Poilley, councilor o vote 5 Yea 3 No I Abstained
abstaining: Itto pass.' Voting Yes B[oRy Cox,
Hswining Me
ley Olde[ failed to Pase.fadgno gmf majority Fesunkel,Lebowititsullivanlvan
Abstaining Mc CartTyy ' by voting
yes; iirown, -andnno votes. CwnciloraVot{ng No Tilley, NMeeCa[,
voting yea: ouncilo Cox,_Ing no:
.and Willey ghatafpfng Nc Cartiy
Amended by deleting Affirmed &i Sullivan, counWheeler
and W voting no: cilNcel, f l t 1
Modified as follows Tilley, wbeelex id Willey. Councilor gas {$$e`;'ar&YSIYU (ec.
tai 'ng: Mc Cartb 3 prose evat
Vote 6Yes 2 No 1 Abetale //)) 3 no 1 Abstained Voting Yee
Voting Yes Frankel,Lebwity, bLlliven _ Q(�,Congo, Cox, Lebowitz, Sullivan,
Tilley,Wheeler,W111ey, CI CLR Tilley Voting No Frankel,
Voting No Hrwa,Cox Abstaining McCarthy wheeler,Willey
Passed as emended 5 yes 3 no l.abstained Abstalnaing Me �Canby
Voting yen Frankel,Lebwit2,9u111ven, BACK-UP iAT8RIAL FII80 IN
Waeeler,Willay Voting No BTom,Cex,Tilley IFRAN,WAY PENALTY CONTACT,
Abstaining Me Cartky 7 'Ity C e
c /
StyAek
IN CITY COUNCIL
October 28, 1985
Referred to Bistoric preservation
Committee - Consider next meeting.
IN CITY C00NCIL
wember 13, 1985
Amend by deleting reversed 6
Modified failed to pass by the
following yes and no votes.
Councilors voting yes: grown,
Cox, Lebowitz and Tilley. Councilors
voting no: Frankel, Sullivan, WM¢ler
and Willey. .Councilor abstaining:
mcCarthy.
Amend by deleting affirmed b mrdified
failed to pass by the following yes
and no votes. Councilors voting yes:
Frankel, Sullivan,W]m eler and Willey.
Caoncelors voting no: grown, Car, Lebowitz
and Tilley. Councilor abstaining:
McCarthy
Amended by deleting affirmed s mndified
passed by the following yes and no votes.
Councilors voting yes: Frankel, Lebowitz, Sullivan,
Tilley, Wheeler and Willey. Councilors voting no:
Brown, Cox. Councilor abstaining: McCarthy.
Passed as Amended by the following yesand no votes.
Councilors voting yes: Frankel, tebo✓Sta, Sullivan,
Wheeler and Willey. Councilors voting no: Flows,
Car and Tilley. Councilor abstaining: MCCarthY.
IN CITY COUNCIL
N CITY COUNCIL
November 25, 1985
December 30, 1985
Vote in favor of Chairman in
Amended by deleting
reference to nummbof days
reversed and adding
for reconsiderationpassed by
affirmed passel by
the following yen and no votes.
the following yes and no
Councilors voting yes: Brown,
votes. -Councilors votin
Cox, Frankel, Lebwitz and
yes. Wasson, Cox,
Sullivan. Councilors voting no.
Lilley. , Sullivan and
Tilley, Wheeler and Willey.
Tilley. Councils[,
McCarthy.I1a[
Councilor ation
voting n Frankel,
ping:
passed by the
Reconsfollowing
and Willey.
dee aM n -
yes
Councilor abstaining:
Councilor voting
Cox,
McCarthy.
Lebow SullivanTax8and
Cox, livaand Tilley.
Order failed
lade[ failed to pass for
voting
Coerce lois voting no: Frenkel,
Councilors
lack of majority by
Wheeler and Willey. Councilor
the followingyea and
absVote
Co
vote a. CBrown, ors
votes.
to ref r to[MF.
Vote to refer to Preservation
Brown, Cm:,
Co
2n
mitteenecomb aid c ee ids[ Zed meeting
consider
and Sullivan.
Lebowitz an
in cenembex by the followCouncilors
Councilors voting noz
Councils
oteved
yes and no votes. voting
Frenkel, Tilley,
bcwitzlors
Fes: Brown, Cox, Lebowitz, Sullivan
Wheeler and Willey.
and Tilley. Councilors votingoo
Councilorabstaining:
Frankel, Wheeler and
d-WilleyCouncilor
irCaiNhy.
abstaining; McCarthy.
-
IN CITY COUNCIL
October 28, 1985
Referred to Historic Preservation
Coamittee - Consider next meeting
IN CITY COUNCIL
November 13, 1985
Amend by deleting reversed 6
Modified failed to pass by the
following yes and no votes.
Councilors voting yes: Hravn,
CM, Lebowitz and Tilley. Councilors
voting no: Frankel, Sullivan, wheeler
and Willey. Councilor abstaining:
McCarthy -
Roamed by deleting affirmed a uod1fied
failed to pass by the following yea
and no votes. Councilors voting yes:
Frankel, Bullivan,WMeler and Willey.
Councilors voting no: Brwn, Cox, leba itz
and Tilley. Councilor abstaining:
Mccartby
Ascended by deleting affixmed 6 lified
passed by the following yes and no votes.
Councilors voting yes: Frankel, Lebowitz, Sullivan,
Tilley, Wheeler and Willey. Councilors voting n .
green, Cox Councilor alstai ing: NCCarthy.
Passed as Amended by the following yes and no votes.
Councilors voting yes: Frankel, iebadtz, Sullivan,
wheeler and Willey. Councilors voting no: House,
Cox and Tilley. Councilor abstaining: McCarthy.
IN CITY COUNCIL
IN CITY COUNCIL
November 25, 1985
December 30, 1985
Vote in favor of Chairman in
Amended by deleting
reference to number of days
reversed and adding
for r Consideration passed by
affirmed passed by
the following yes and no votes.
the following yes and no
Councilors voting yes: Brawn,
votes. Councilorsa
vot'n
Coq Frankel, Iabowitz and
yes: Brown, Cox,
Sullivan. Councilors voting no:
Lebowitz, Sullivan and
Tilley, Wheeler and Willey.
Tilley. Councilors
Councilor abstaining: McCarthy,
voting no: Frankel,
Reconsideration passed by the
Wheeler and Willey.
following yes and no votes.
Councilor abstaining:
Councilors voting yea: Brawn,
McCarthy.
Cox, laWsitz, Sullivan and Tilley.
Order failed to pass for
Councilors Voting no:: Frankel,
lack of majority by
Wheeler and Willey.Councilor
thefallowing yes and
abstaining: McCarthy.
no votes. Cowcilors
Vote to refer to Historic Preservation
voting yes: Brown, Car,
Commebbee and consider 2nd meeting
Lebowitz and Sullivan.
n December passed by the following
Councilors voting no.
yes and no votes. Councilors voting
Frankel, Tilley,
yes: Brown, Cox, Lebowitz, Sullivan
Wheeler and Willey.
and Tilley. Councilors voting no!
Councilor abstaining:
Frankel, wheeler and Willey. Councilor
McCarthy.
abstaining: McCarthy.
IN CITY COUNCIL
9c[obe[ 26, 1985 y
Neferred to Historic preservation
Committee - Consider next meeting.
IN CITY COUNCIL
November 13, 1985
Amend by deleting reversed d
Modified failed to pass by the
following yes and no votes.
Councilors voting Fes: Freon,
Car, Lebowitz and Tilley. Councilors
voting no: Frankel, Sullivan, Wheeler
and Willey. Councilor abstaining:
McCarthy.
Amend by deleting affirmed 6 unified
failed to pass by the following yes
and no votdn. Councilors voting yes:
Frankel, Su133van,Wpeler and Willey.
Councilors voting no: Breen, COX, lebwitz
and Tilley. Councilor abstaining:
McCarthy
Amaw:ded by deleting affirmed 6 modified
passed by the following yes and no votes.
Councilors voting yes: Frankel, Lebowitz, Sullivan,
Tilley, Wheeler and Willey. Councilors voting. no.
BrOxn, Cox. Councilor abstaining: McCarthy.
sted as Amended by the following yes and no votes.
Councilors voting yes: Frankel, Lebowitz, Sullivan,
Wheeler aM Willey. Councilors voting no: Brown,
Cox and Tilley. Councilor abatainirq: McCarthy.
IN CITY COUNCIL
IN CITY COUNCIL
November 25, 1985
Decanter 30, 1985
vote in favor Of Chairman in
Ame:dee by deleting
reference to number of days
reversed and adding
for reconsideration passe] by
affirmed passed by
the following yes and no votes,
the following yes and no
Councilors voting yen: grown,
votes. Councilors votin
CSx, Frankel, lebomntz and
yea: Brown, Cox,
Sullivan. Councilors voting no.
Icboxitz, Sullivan and
Tilley, Wheeler and Willey.
Tilley. Councilors
Councilor abstaining: McCarthy.
voting no: Frankel,
sideration passed by the
Wheeler and Willey.
following yes and Do votes.
Councilor abstaining:
Councilors voting yes: Brown,
McCarthy.
Cox, Lebowitz, Sullivan and Tilley.
never failed. to pass for
Councilors voting no : Frankel,
lack of majority by
Wheeler add Willey.Councilor
the following yea and
abstaining: maCarthy.
no votes. Councilors
vote to refer to Historic preservation
voting yes: green, Cox,
Committee and consider 2nd meeting
labwitz and Sullivan.
n December passed by thefollowingCouncilors
voting no.
yes and no votes. Councilors voting
Frankel, Tilley,
yes: Brown, Cm:, iabwitz, Sullivan
Wheeler and Willey.
and Tilley. Councilorsvoting no:
Councilor abstaining:
Frankel, Wheeler and Willey. Councilor
Mwa[thy.
abstaining: McCarthy.
IN CITY CWNCIL
October 28, 1985 1
Referred to Historic Preservation
Cosmittee, - Consider next meeting.
IN CITY COUNCIL
November 13, 1985
Amend by deleting reversed s
Mcdifie3 failed to pass by the
following yes and no votes.
Councilors voting yes: Brown,
Cox, Lebowitz and Tilley. Councilors
voting no: Frankel, Sullivan, Wheeler
and Willey. Councilor abstaining:
McCarthy.
Amend by deleting affirmed c modified
failed to pass by the following yes
and no versa. Councilors voting yes:
Frankel, Sullivan,Wheeler and Willey.
Councilors voting no: Frown, Cox, Lebowitz
and Tilley. Councilor abstaining:
McCarthy
Aoended by deleting affirmed s modified
passed by the following yes and no .votes.
Councilors voting yes: Frankel, Lebowitz, Sullivan,
Tilley, Wheeler and Willey. Councilors voting no:
Brown, Cox. Councilor abstaining: McCarthy.
Passed as A:a:ded by the following yes and no votes.
Councilors voting yes: Frankel, Lebowitz, Sullivan,
Wheeler and Willey. Conncilors voting n
Car and Tilley. Councilor abstaining: McCarthy.
IN CITY CCUNCIL
IN CFM COUNCIL
November 25, 1985
December 30, 1985
Vete in favor of Chairman i
Amended by deleting
reference to number of days
reversed and adding
for reconsideration passed by -
affirmed passed by
the following yes and no votes.
the following and no
Councilors voting yes: Brown,
yes
^
votes Councilors votinc
Cox, peankel, Iehoxitz and
Brown, Cox,s "
yes: B
Sullivan. Councilors voting no.
lebowitz, Sullivan and
Tilley, Wheeler and Willey.
Tilley. Councilors
Councilor abstaining: N arthy.
voting no: Frankel,
Reconsideration passed by the
Wheeler and Willey.
following yes and no votes.
Canceler abstaining:
Councilors voting yes: Brown,
McCarthy.
Cox, Iebwitz, Sullivan and Tilley.
Order failed to pass for
Councilors voting no: Frankel,
lack of majority by
Wheeler and Willey. Councilor
the following yes and
abstaLung: N Carthy.
no votes. Councilor
Vote to refer to Historic Preservation
voting yea: Brown, Con,
Committee and Consider 2nd .meeting
Lebowitz and Sullivan.
n December passed by the following
Counoi loss voting no.
yes and no votes. Councilors voting
Frankel, Tilley,
yes: Brcmm, Cox, Nebwitz, Sullivan
Wheeler and Willey.
and Tilley. Councilors voting now
Councilor abstaining:
Frankel, Wheeler and Willey. Councilor
NoCarchy.
abstaining: mcCarthy.