HomeMy WebLinkAbout1961-03-27 98-N ORDERIntroduced by Councilor Keith, March 27, 1961 98-N
CITY OF BANGOR
(TIRE.) (OrbeSr..._.. Receivial.conaro atum From City Maeager _. _.
9e: Kenduakeag stream
By Bu City Cm nil of the City of Baayor:
ORDERED,
TEAT the attached communication from the City Manager is
hereby received.
P E C E I V E D
1961 March 23 3sW P.M.
City Clerks Office
Bangor, Maine
IM CITY COUNCIL
March 27, 1961
PASSED
ORDER
Title,
...._Receiving_ CM9mYn14atioR.. from. City
_Macager„3e5,_ KeMvsk£a9.$tneam.. _..
Intendnml and filed by
SVt+.Mfo OF ESMATED COST
I.
Parking Area
a. Hetalning walls fill and pavement
,P933, SVO
2,020 ft. at 8462 =
b. Approaches adjacent to parking area
Yater Street $3,500
York Street 3,500
Hancock Street 3,000
:;ashington Street 3,300
iemoval cribbing
above G3. 17.0 31
141400
c. Ornamental railing
45,000
d. Steel Stairs to State & Hammond Sts.
2,300
o. Lighting
27,500
f. Drainage for parking area & approaches
cutoffs & graded areas
72,500
g. Painting & parking Selands
$ 7�.._
Contingencies & engineering 'CVP
220.400
Subtotal Parking Area
$1,322,500
II.
amp from uashington St. Bridge 15,500
Contingencies & engineering 2DN 3,100
18,600
III.
Poot Bridge 11,Ooo
Contingencies & engineering 20;u 2,200
13,200
IV.
Pier Head at State Street 48,000
Contingencies & engineering 2N 9,600
57,600
V.
Vehicular Bridge 46,"
Contingencies & engineering 20'$ 9.200
55, Sroo
144,600
VI.
Sewers & appurtenances
West aide
126,500
Peat side
94.000
Contingencies & engineering 2Z
44,1W
Subtotal Sewers & Appurtenances
26
'' 46
$ 00
1 ��a I�+u
Say $1,732,000 TOTAL
The estimated coat of the Parking Area
with wane, fills, pavement, etc., is
$1,322,500
The estimated cost of senora and
appurtenances to
264,600
F; dng a total of
$1,587,100
If the ;lamp from 'washdngton Street be
Snclvdcd, the estimated cost is
$18,600 more or a total of
$1,605,700
The Foot D Idga Is estimated to cost
$131200 trhich added to the above
would mare the total estimated coat
$1,6180900
The rler Head and Vehicular ➢rldga are
estimated to cost $112,800, which If
included with the above item would
nal-0 the total amount
$12731,700
METCALF Sc EDDY
-, E N a 1 N E E R RL 61.111 .
SUNTLER BUILDING
BOSTON IS. WASSACNYSRTS
....,_... J -Bangor Kenduekeag Adv. March 14, 1961
Mr. Joseph R. Coupal, Jr.
City Manager
City Hall
Bangor, Maine
SIIBJBCT: Kenduskeag Stream and Parking
Project. I
Dear Mr. Coupal:
Our report of July 25, 19 ted, "$� slew of the
possibility that the open etre ch el may D� covered at
some future time, it is doub if a expense for the Pier
Head and Vehicular Bridge is ustif at this time."
We understand si able progress has been
made in providing o -street ar ng at various locations,
however, there woul still be a a ious need for additional
parking spaces even after the reposed Kenduskeag parking
areae shall De provide .
It seems preD8D t the requirements for additional
parking a ace would ustlfy covering the areas between the
proposed alls of t Kenduskeag Stream within not more than
about 5 ye would then provide at least 200 spaces
in addition spaces, which the first stage would pro -
If the Vehicular Bridges are included in the first
stage, only about 310 parking spaceswouldbe provided in the
areae between the stream channel walls and the Crib lines.
If the Vehicular Bridges are not included, there would
still be sufficient access to each parking area to permit full
use.
Mr. Joseph R. Coupal, Jr. 2.
March 14, 1961
Our letter to you dated March 33 1961, indicated the
estimated cost of the Renduskeag Stream Improvement and
Proposed Parking Areas between Washington Street and Hammond
and State Streets, to be $1,732,000, including provisions for
the Pier Head and Vehicular Bridges connecting the easterly
and westerly areas, and for the walls so designed, that the
stream could be covered over and the additional space made
available for parking in the future.
The estimated coat of the Xenduakeag Stream Improvement
and Parking Areas, if the Vehicular Bridges and Pier Head are
not included, but with the walls designed to permit covering
the stream channel at some future time, is about $1,619,000.
This would provide area for about 350 parking spaces and
appurtenances.
We understand that the amount of $1,619,000 is within
the amount authorized for the project.
It is our opinion, from a Bound economic standpoint,
It would not be prudent to provide the Pier Head and
Vehicular Bridges as part of the stream improvement and park-
ing project at this time. We therefore recommend that the
project be authorized without the Pier Head and Vehicular
Bridges.
Very truly yours,
METCA & EDDY
BY �"
JWR: ac Sohn M, As ond, Jr.
i/
METCALF Fac EDDY
E N G I N E E R S N
BOSTON 16 MASSACHUSETTS
March 3, 1961
Km. Joseph R. Coupal, Jr.
City [anger
Bangor, ;!alne
Dear Sir:
the data for the he nga recently
aide of the Kenduskeeg
e revSsee our repo on Kenduskeag
Propos P SnS Are He teem
Nammo and g to Stem
6 dated
prep d des 6 taking into con -
ns ah b- he boring data and the
lee have studied
made along the westerly
Stream Channel. qe hav
Stream Improvement and
Washington Street and
July 25, 1958 and have
alderation the Cond1t10
probable scouring aepy
Assuming tUPalmgNhe.west
d1 one at the proposed location
for the east wallto ondltions Indicated by the
recent borl dot side, the eatlenate of coat
has been sed arrant prices and to Include
same mod Stationign and certain requirements
MkIfloati a In the design are as follows:
1. s to be supported on steel H piles with
the bottom of wall footings at 31. 2.0 and
top of walls El. 23.0.
2. A Separate parking area drainage system to
be provided to drain each side to a float don -
trolled pump for drainage of the parking areas
and areas at buildings during high water in
the Kenduskeag Stream.
Mr. Joseph R. Coupal, Jr. 2.
March 39 1961
3• Interceptor sewers to he 66 in. dlaneter on
the west and 42 in. diameter R.C. pipe on the
east with no overflows to the Kenduckeag
Stream between Washington Street and Hammond
and State St^seta. No manholes on newer lines
In the parking area or where ground elevation
is below 24.0.
4. Sheeting to be driven to 1. .10.0 on the etrocn
side of the wall footings to prevent excessive
scour under the wall and reduce the tendency for
water to pass through the material under the wall
frau the stream channel.
The wall on piles was estimated with steel H piles
versus timber piles and It was found there would be little
difference in cost. Therefore, the steel H pile design was
selected because of the alder spacing of pile bents. Pamely,
30 ft. with steel piles compared to 5 ft, with timber piles.
The estimated cost with a pedestrian bridge and a
vehicular bridge, is $1,732,000, insluding allowances for
contingeneiea and engineering.
A sunmary of the catlmated cost is shorn on the
accompanying pages.
Very truly yours,
M6xC & EDDY
Lit //
StR:ao !Tori N. ✓Jr.
Boager, she seam a/Maine --- The Ganuay to Maine's North Woods and Smile" Rosen
(gag of zrngor, Maine
GaNCUTIVE DEPARTMENT
Bangor City council
City Half
Bangor, Maine
Gentlemen:
March 23, 1961
After the Referendum on the Renduskeag Stream parking
Project was passed on October 10, 1960, City Council instructed the
City Manager to contact representatives of the firm Metcalf k Eddy
to discuss with them the possibility of engaging them for Engineering
services to prepare pians and specifications including working drawings
and put due project out to bid. Mr. John Raymond appeared before the
City Council and discussed this project and indicated that it was his
feeling that additional borings should be taken in the stream bed to
determine design specifications.
Accordingly, Northeast Soil Services was engaged and they
took 23 test borings on the west aide of the stream during late fall of
1960 but before additional test borings could be taken on the east side of
the stream, the stream froze completely and ice conditions made it
impossible to complete this project.
After several conferences with Mr. Raymond, it was determined
that on the basis of the information obtained by the test borings on the
est bank, they should give us a revised estimate on the coat athia
parking project to determine whether or not it would be within the estimated
$1, 650, 000 allocated for it
Bangor City Council Page 2 March 23, 1961
Attached herewith you will find reports dated March 3rd
and March 14th from Metcalf & Eddy which do indicate that this project
is feasible and is possible of achievement within the $1,650, 000. While
you will note that they estimate about a quarter of a million for contin-
gencies and engineering, the total cost including the vehicular bridge
and ramps would run to $1,731,700, they recommend that the project
be constructed without the vehicular bridge and pierheads. They, point
out in their report of March Milt, that there would be 40 additional
parking spaces available Athe bridge and pierhead were not constructed,
that there would be a savings of about $113, 000 which would bring their
total estimate well under the $1, 650, 000 allocated and in addition it is
probable that the entire stream will be covered for additional parking in
the not too distant future in which event this $113, 000 would be wasted.
Therefore it is the recommendation of the administration that
the firm of Metcalf & Eddy be engaged to prepare final plans and specif
cations sufficient to be put out for bid and also to assist the City Council
to determination of the best bid arta that we proceed immediately with the
authorization of the bond issue is the am cont of the $1, 650, 000. In
telephone conversation with Metcalf & Eddy on Wednesday, March 22W,
Mr. Sohn Raymond indicated mat prior to the Council meeting to be held
on Monday, March 26th, he would be able to furnish as with an estimated
cost of their engineering services for this project.
If you have any questions relative to this matter, I shall be
glad to discuss [hem withyou.
Yours truly,
IA
COY MANAGE
SAG/sc
Attached