HomeMy WebLinkAbout1992-01-22 Finance Committee MinutesFiname IX tfee
dammoJ 22, 1992 a: 5:00 p.m.
}finutee
mu ars in Attadanca: .btm Sraggr .Tare Sail, Gerry Baldecci, Pat
Hlamtetter ad kictaxd Score
1. Gcuncil O-Mjustmeat of Saes Pcm�M
Sohn Frawley briefed Ue Fiimca C ttee on the status of the h dget of
various sear pro]a . Of the nice projects which axe either untleiway
or crnpleted, five ase stem to have fired project costs belay Ue
originally bdgat i mat. Fos.' other projects will emxed the orfgixal
budget. Toll xeviaed arch prolat with the FLa*ce C ttee, all
raRu� that the Camdttea avmeM to t full Cn u a C u
Ostler which would transfer fulls between the various Projects to acommt
for uMexxuns all oveaaa. The ret effect of all of Uveae tra fexs will
be rexo. The Firoice Gmedttee vmtei to xavmeM to tM Cascil that
theFe adlustmPm= be vada.
2. hxacil ONeo-Amni of tract to �l Coretrvetion Ova 1Hagc Saar
Ja`�n Frawley d scribed the Psolcot in questiwi, all :evicted the hide
adiich tad F n m fved for $1TTe aigixcer's estimate was
that Um pxojeac roultl cost $130,000.30,000. 85. low hihier is Caig3
of $100,000, in the ley of $100,426.05. Siace this award is fn a by
of $100,000, W. Frwley iirlicat»i that final active wvultl th xeguixe3 by
the CityCoto i Fiance Comdttee voted w rause ul approval. of
to
this muxd the full
Ccweil.
3. G cil Order-Fatahliahina Local Ialnr ikuixmants for Maior
mu....» ,... l oiecte
City staff pxeseMal to t]e Fixa:cz Cmmdttee the draft of a Courcil
0 der which xauld sFabliah a rgT� Uat a parcmt� of all labor
mplcy x on czxt in city carettucGion oontracts mut mavrc in penoanmt
x�5denw in the State of Faire. The Ottley, as Pxesanted, offaz i a
n�mher of opts to t Camdttee xegaxding both t dollar value of the
cony cte to be cvuexed s well as tis pexcata of local labor to ba
squired. Prvposai dollar value for contracts to ! cc a xexe
$1,000,000, $750,000, or $5000000. 14e _ eta;° of local labor to be
ragui was 508, 664, or 158.
After sere tliscussion, the Finale C tt xecamendal that this iiau
to placsi on the City Causal agenda with the xecm:m Uon for
appnrval. At the suggstion of Caurcilor Saldacoi all Courcilor fry ,
it was agreed that the pads would be sant forward witbmt a specific
recam ndation on t}e options ouui . The Camittee felt that this
would be appropriate and would allw Ue full Ccoreil to tl ate the
apptolxiate numbers to be ixclidei in Ue fatal o der.
4. Oraacil Oriar�-ilill Collas[ Me Ten -Se onde t
Sohn fY ley reported to the Finance mitt tlat rte work d his
being pmSosetl on aux o flw £achiria plan hes
i:dicatei that it may be cost effective to cvnsfder :redl.£icatiom to the
primary and secvtlaxy ttea Plan¢ to allow the plan to frc:xzaee its
Peak capacity Euro its currently designs c ity of 30 million gall
per day to tle 43 million gallon per day which the exiacing intsxce t
seeer can deliver to the plant. 2>p paxPase of this prosect would be
- to provide for se'ondvxy, treatment of a Portion of the course flow the
City enq+eniencea during storm periods. 1ha project would require the
installation of additional �, some yard piping and possibly an
additional primary clarif a or basin. Pa liminary estinated costs for
this Project rage b ee $1M and 51.4et.
Sohn indicated that both City staff and our sewer cwaultants feel that
this cork may, best be accaFdistea as a part of the present construction
project do order to minimize disruptions at the plant, potentially fore
fewer costs in teas of redoing work that it is already in progress, and
potentially recopvdmg exrr soon of a completion date for the construction
contract from EPA and M.
flZx-Hill has would
be a study
gml We is aldle imo coo phases. ted
first posse mala be a study phase which multl be .••a° pre i,msliately
and which mala further dedine the las well as ar of the pccycsed
dmq�mvaments at the anearnar plant as well as analyze The sera riate
Pro+sent ase wIl cosi t alct of delay flat 00.62 a sect uts say have.
study ptmsa the mat l detaileci de $40ign of0. 'lad aecatl ire of the
Project mala be the actual de Phan ensign of the aaaltiaal 0nprwe-
nerts needed. 9e oast of this plass is estimated to 1E $65,000.
1 City Engineer xaammYel co the Ccumsittee that it rennrend to the
full Council the adoption of a Council Ctdar which would imoeitetely
authorize the study place and furtler authorize the design phase pendmg
receipt of appy.oval, of the study by EPA and F&P and subject to subsequent
aPProval of the Finan -e Cmmittee to proceed. The Fdnance Cveittee
approved xecamwding adoption of this Council order to the fell Cooed.
5. vacant Bnaineaziro peracaoant Fbaition
Jahn Frawley and Tim Xing briefed the Finance Camittee m the used for
filling m misting vacset position in the Engineering Department. Tne
vacant position in question resulted from the retive eat of malt Luo,
the Assistant City Engineer, last steer. Sohn indicated that the
position is xequixed because of the extent of sewer cork currently being
.••+^^'•b^, the neetl to Provide a regi semi esginser to su�ise the
work of our roe -registered engireers do dug design on sewer projects,
and as the result of analysis which indicates that hiring an indlvidoal
to d this will be less e pensive to the City than contracting for such
secvicas. Sohn also pointed out that the test of this position will have
no n act on the Geral Fund since the the of this individual will all
be charged back to varies capital projector on which M on aha rods.
1de Furore Committee, approved Ding to advertise for and fill this
position.
6. Shared Esu' Proposal
Dewe Pellegrino indicated to the Finance Camitem that he had been
receiving proposals from varicus energygnt, electrical supply,
and temperature, control cagiarnies to instsllemeriy conservation
equip t at m met in various City buildings. Under these proposals,
payment for the egufpent would woe from the energy gy savings realized
after installation of the equ t. The wgany p csing the
i.ugrzwen6nt meld upfront the capital caste. Typlcslly, the City mala
sign a fire to ten year contrect agreeing to the wi¢wy pay 70-00% of
any savings fns the haze enetgl•rest that is eatablielei frac our
acorn payable records. Toe purpzu of the briefing was to determine
whedcr tlue Finance Camittee was interested fn t City pnsui g formal.
requests for proposals fon such an undertakiW.
W. Pellegrino indfcaTad that in tha early 80'e the City hal Laedved
sbmllar inqu= ee fmn such com r cs. At that time, proposals xeLz Talon
Wt the Cavcil did M vdsh W proccetl with Dien. Prior to ,,..-ie.ra4:�g
sup action, mora wished to deteendre iron the Cmnmittee wlettcr *^we res
supprrt for such a Pxgneal.
After same discussion of now such proposals wormed ad the terve ami
coMitionw which xwld be Lrvolved, the Fdraere coa n tree approval
Proceeding to issue a Bequest for Proposal.
]. Autdwization to Fill tree •.__w Fgyipa3lt Ooerat I Position -Public
ALUvs Stockes ird icatai that flee Public i4oLlm Oep�t has had a
recent vacanry in t3ea d I classification. Prior to this vxency, four
posdtlmc had been £moon in Aeblic Pbila—too M II's and two Foiestey
W.ulaxs. t4. St.. -w.= inddcaTei that he is xegeesting to fill this
position which is a position assigned to operate one of the City's three
sddewauc srowplas or, whan rot Plowing, IS assigned to the Depeti'maet
arexgmcy truck. W. Stockus inei atai that rot filling the position
would czeate difficulties in our sidsmelk mcnTlaaing aha would also
red=s productivity and xeaioesivawss of the work ladled by the
encs Jency truck as.
The City Manager dMdca that authonizing this be filled
would not c a pre em- First, AnWdc ti ks will Lorain with fuer
frozen posit . Secnrd, the City is now familiar with the effects of
the State's helgat p oblen on tie City's =vont year b dget and is
pteparal to mete budget adjust ant which do not necessitate leaving this
Position unfilled. Third, he intl atm that as the number of frozen
P itione inetensei, tImne w an ireceasieg lfloalih=i that any
additional v armies would raludre filling. A[Yer sme discussion, the
Finn es C®mfttae approved filling this position. Ceunoilw Baldacci
wtei against this motion becaase he felt that tie reed m fill the
position had rot been eufficfen:ly dxamented aha supported by City
shaff.
8. Bids:
a.
The anmel ctxtracc Eor xydmgen A3oxide for the Wastaatter
TLm PI was araLdel To W.N. $huLtleff Capvey, the low Lesponeive
tuned, for 43.5 cenEs per pound. IAst yaw's mice was 65.9 cents per
Pound.
b. The bid fon Mable open flaw v=d for tic euhllm Setvicas Sewen
Division was awaLdei to Marsh-dbBix , the low hither, at $52,650.00.
Ttds is for tan sonitors.
C. Pomahle, vsatleL oofI hssd held c Uter for tle Rblic Services
Steer Division was awenied to dusky Cagmters, Imo., the sole source
suFplier, 7 e original bid price of tha cmpury was $3,995.00. Mile
pexyl the SG%Alr Mlintenenre sqp inba dent, ixdicaied that he had
rey bated this price f .sow. with irmsky Cmpetets and that ticy vcae now
willing to sell the unit w the City fon slightly less than $3,000.00.
9. Police Officer N inq6 D
The City .Manager also reportm to the Finanoe Committee that the City
world lila to begin the process of establishing a hiring list £or police
officers. At the pmsa time, there are two frozen polioa officer
vacvdies in the DepSrtaent. In aeWtien, a Lecwnt 4bdmLs' Canpinatign
settlement with � police offices wlll scon insult in a th
vacard y. Finally, two ediitiaal police persoael are conterVlating
mtiramnt within the reit several mvrcha. Mould all of tide coin to
pass, this weld leave the dice Dep� with five vacarci�. At the
present tine, the Dep.TM,enr ie operating at sdrdnonn m� levels. %
we approach tJe swmer, dsovei for police services in the daa�town etas
wlll ircrease a wi11 be cmVou ed by aminal vacation scM es. awn
this situation, and recognizing U t the process of establishing a hiring
list for police officers my take w lag w three to four �, the
City Faager msmmeetlsi that we begin the process of for
camlfdatea. The Finance cawittee approval this recmmeMatfon.