HomeMy WebLinkAbout2008-01-28 08-077 ORDERDate: zn, zone 08 077
Item/Subject Order, Authorizing Amendment to [.ease with the New Castle Hotel Corporation to
Extend the Term and Mod fy the Formula for Calculating Rent
Responsible Depmtmend Airport
The New Castle Hotel Corporation will be investing eight million dollars in the Four Points Sheraton located
at the Airport. This will inw1w substantial exterior and Interior work which will affect hotel operations during
construction. In order to support the financing and amortization of this investment, New Castle has
requested a 13 year lease extension, providing for a 40 year remaining lease term. They have also
requested a modification in the formula for calculating rent in recognition of the of vemq losses that will
exist during the construction period and for a period of time thereafter and the additional debt that must be
serviced. The current formula for calculating rent includes a base rent pus a percentage of certain hotel
revenues. Under the proposed terms, a greater percentage of the revenue to the Airport will shift to the
fixed base rent from the variable percentage rent. Although this will decrease rental income to Airport during
the initial few years, it will provide a more stable revenue flow and the Airport will have fully recovered the
reduced revenues after seven years. Beyond that point, we project that the airport will see an increase in
annual revenues over the remaining term. In addition and based an the proposed renovations, City
Assessing conservatively estimates an increase in property tax revenue to the City of approximately $50,000
annually, a B %increase, even during the initial fore year periotl of the revised lease.
Rebecca Hump
Department Head
Manager's Comments:
This has been discussed on several occasions by the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, which
recommends your approval. The Committee particularly noted that the situation with New Castle is
different from other drywairport leases in that New Castle pays a premium due to its close location to the
alrport terminal, the presence of a firs[ class hotel connected to the terminal provides an amenity for
travelers using BIA, and, under the terms of the ease, the City can take possession of the building M the
expiration of the lease.
G.`
Ory Manager
Associated Information: Memo with supposing material from Airport
Budget Approval:
nance Director
Legal Approval:
�- Ci Solicitor
Introduced for
X Passage
First Reading
_ Rehnral
Page I of 1
03 077
r° January 2a. zoos
AuigMbCO lorPal r
CITY OF BANGOR
(TIRE.) ORDER, Authorizing Amendment to Lease with the New Castle Hotel
Corporation to Extend the Term and Modify the Formula for Calculating Rent.
WHEREAS, The New Castle Hotel Corporation leases property at the Bangor
International Airport for the operation of the Sheraton Four Points Hotel;
and
WHEREAS, The New Castle Hotel Corporation has committed to Invest an additional
eight million dollars in renovations to the property; and
WHEREAS, Both parties desire td amend the lease term for an additional thirteen
years in order to amortize this Investment; and
WHEREAS, The renovations will result in increased revenue over the remaining term
of the lease and B is beneficial to troth parties to amend the formula for
calculating the rent due,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDERED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
BANGOR,THAT
the Airport is authorized to execute a lease amendment with New Castle Hotel
Corporation to extend the lease term for an additional thirteen years and to modify the
formula for calculating rent in accordance with the proposal that has been reviewed and
recommended by the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee and in a form
approved by the Cry Solicitor or Assistant City Solicitor.
IN CITY C CIL
Sanuan 28, 2008
Motion {fade and Seconded '
for Passage
Notion Doubted
Vote: 7-t
Councilors voting Yes: D'ffiEi
Farrington, Gratvtck, Haves, Palmer
Stone and Wheeler
Councilors voting No: NlaniChette
Coum
m lox Absent: Create
Pap
ITTCN.
�1
# 08-Q7Z
0 a p E a
I
vith the
h Hotel
moth Che. the
CTern Hotel ift t F
' to BZCeod [he Term and NodiEv [h'e Formols
for Calculmtl g Hest
AmlmdbCsmdbr 1'(1vAY'N �
A 677
BGR �
INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT
Iz14zYIP9CIbill aI
TO:
Transportation and Infrastructure Committee
CC:
Ed Barrett, Norm Hellmann, Debbie Cyr, Penelope Olson
FROM:
Rebecca Hupp
DATE:
January 3, 2008
RE:
Iease Amendment Request by New Castle Hotel
As previously discussed, the New Castle Hotel Corporation, owners of the Four Points Sheraton
located at the Airport, has a lease agreement with the Airport that is In effect until 2016 with
two ten-year options to renew. New Castle leases the land from the Airport and owns the
building. The terms of this lease are very similar to our other lease agreements where the
Airport is guaranteed a base rental plus a percentage of revenue. Currently, there is a $60,000
base rent, which Is reduced by an amount equal to one-half of the real estate taxes paid to the
City. In addition M the base rent, three and one-half percent (3 +h%) of 91 'h%of room
revenue and 2% of flood and beverage revenue is paid to the Airport as rent New Castle also
pays property texas to Me City on Me full value of the land, building, and personal property.
The City has no similar land lease arrangements with hotel operators in Bangor. Other hotels
operate on privately owned land. The rental rate for other Airport tenants may have similar
formulas for calculating their rental rates but they occupy leased space In the terminal.
New Castle is requesting a lease amendment to extend the lease an additional 10 years and to
change the formula for calculating Me rental rate. New Castle requests that the override
assessed an the room revenue be amended as indicated in the following table.
Ground Rant AssunnRons
Current
nos
2009
2010
2011
2012
Base ReM
$W.O
T.-, ii
888.0
$90.0
$9T.0
$95.0
%uf 91.5% or Rooms Revenue
3.5%
0.0%
1.5%
2.0%
2.6%
3015%
%dFostl eM Bevera .Revenue
Te%
00%
1.5%
20%
2.0%
2.0%
please note that under the proposed terms, a greater percentage of Me revenue M the Airport
will shift to the fixed base rent, and, after eleven years, the Airport will have fully recovered the
reduced annual revenues from years 1-4.
Far many years, New Caste has been considering eMensive renovations to the Sheraton Four
Points. However, during construction, the hotel will experience a negative cash flow of $1.5
million. This presents a significant obstade that needs m be overcome as each Individual
property within the system must be self-sustaining. The New Cashe Corporation, at the urging
of Its local hotel manager, is prepared to invest approximately $8 million during the first half of
2008 to renovate the building. The proposed modifications will add valuable space on the lower
level, upgrade the exterior of the building and renovate and upgrade Me entire lobby area.
These are all improvements that will hold their value past the term of the lease.
J3 077
The proposed renovations will ensure the hotel will meet the specifications necessary to
maintain its branding as a Four Points Sheraton. Maintaining a recognizable brand at the Airport
Is critically important in attracting customers to use the facility. There is no language in the
existing lease requiring any Improvements or imestrnerrcs in the facility. Without Mese
renovations, revenues and profit would likely deteriorate significantly over time. This would be
detrimental M the Airport, in terms of decreased concession revenue and decreased amenity
value to our customers, and to the City in terms of decreased tax revenue.
After renovation, the Company anticipates being able M generate an additional $1.2 million per
year In room revenue. More food and beverage business will also be attracted. This will be
bereficial to the Airport, the City and the hotel.
Based on the prepared! renovations, City Assessing cxnserwitively esdmama an Increase In
property, tax revenue to the City of approximately $50,000 annually, a 69% increase, even
during the initial five year period.
The lease amendments requested by New Castle are reasonable. They will ensure that the $B
million in renovation to the Four Point Sheraton at BIN take place and that the hotel continues
to be an attractive asset to the Airport The imrestment will increase revenues to the hotel and
the Airport and will provide the City General Fund a projected atltlitional $50,000 In annual tax
revenue.
The attached spreadsheet outlines the financial Impact of the three upbers over a 20 year
Period.
;3 U77
Sheraton Four Points
Financial Implications
Estimated
20 Year
Revenues
Option 1: No improvements are made to the existing faclllty
City of Bangor - Taxes 1,532,523
BTA - Concessions 2,409,600
Option 2: $8,000,000 of Improvements under Current Terms
City of Bangor -Taxes 3,308,163
BIA- Concessions 21939,911
Option 3: $8,000,000 of Improvements under Proposed Terms
City of Bangor -Taxes 3,308,163
BIA - Concessions 3,125,161
NO
Jaw
I'm
1,m,
I'm
IJUN
Imm
lump
Imm
INM
]Am
lasw
]Mm
law
lam
44mm
151W
Im"
01,W
IAW
Am
LAIM
mum
Lam
15m,
]5IM,
Mm
DUN,
lb],m
I�
UMMI
MM
Mwt�FmMI
am
MW WAN
MM
mmll
AmA
mm,
(AmI
Am)
MAD)
AW
WM 61AL
KVI
05A
MW
AM
am
am
MIN