HomeMy WebLinkAbout2014-08-18 Finance Committee Minutes
FINANCE COMMITTEE MINUTES
August 18, 2014 @ 5:15 pm
Council Members: Civiello, Sprague, Gallant, Durgin, Graham, Nealley
Staff Members: Conlow, Cyr, Willette, Dawes, Wardwell
Others: Wendy & Frank Carr
1. Consent Agenda
a. Report on Purchase of Used Vehicles
Finance Director Deb Cyr explained that the Fleet Maintenance Supervisor, Bob Dawes,
was authorized to buy 3 used vehicles. At this time the 3 used vehicles have been
purchased that were approved in the FY 2015 budget process. Two are Ford Transit
Connects. One is being used with Dig Safe and the other is being split between
environmental projects and WWTP pre-treatment services. The last vehicle was a large
trailer that is used to move large equipment items around that are used for construction
projects. All were under budget.
Councilor Sprague moved the approval of the consent agenda, Councilor Durgin
seconded, so approved.
2. Bids/Purchasing
a. Photography Services – Parks & Recreation – Monty Rand
Director Cyr explained that a number of programs at Parks & Recreation have
photography needs. We went out to bid for photography services and received 3
responses. We looked for a vendor who offers a variety of packages that parents like
as well as high and low options for packages. Staff recommendation is to award the
contract to Money Rand.
Councilor Sprague moved, Councilor Durgin seconded, so approved.
b. Main Street Safety Improvements – Engineering – Maine Earth - $1,113,975
Director Cyr explained this project that was approved as a part of the FY 2015 budget
which includes the construction and build out of sidewalks of both sides of Main Street,
additional lighting and center medians. 80% of this project is funded from federal grant
monies and the 20% of the local cost is from the downtown TIF monies. Staff
recommendation is to award the contract to low bidder Maine Earth in the amount of
$1,113,975.
Councilor Durgin moved, Councilor Graham seconded, so approve to recommend to full
Council with one doubt (Civiello).
c. Asphalt Paver – Public Works – Milton Cat - $118,322 (with warranty)
Director Cyr explained that part of the FY 2015 budget process it was approved for the
purchase of an asphalt paver for Public Works. Staff recommendation is to award the
contract to Milton Cat for the amount of $118,322 which includes the warranty.
Councilor Nealley moved, Councilor Sprague seconded, so approved to recommend to
full Council.
d. Tracked Excavator – Public Works – Central Equipment - $116,000 (5 Yr
Lease Purchase)
Director Cyr stated that part of the FY 2015 budget process it was approved for the
purchase of a tracked excavator for Public Works. Staff recommendation is award to
the low bidder, Central Equipment, in the amount of $116,000 for a 5 year lease
purchase. This piece of equipment like the asphalt paver above is involved in the buy
back process.
Councilor Durgin moved, Councilor Graham seconded, so approved to recommend to
full Council.
3. Discussion of Potential Savings Committee
Councilor Gallant explained that this subject was brought up by a former employee and
feels it is warranted at this point with the cost savings we are trying to do as a City. It
basically means all depts. and all employees are on board to get cost savings results.
Frank Carr, Bangor resident and former employee, explained that he was involved in
this type of committee while working at another company. All staff was actively
involved taking on responsibility for their own department. It won’t cost anything extra
other than a little of staff time. Employees would make suggestions to the department
head or person on the committee from their department. Depending on how many
suggestions they received would determine how often the committee would meet. It is
not a suggestion box. The employee would find an item that could potentially save the
City money, they would do the research of where the savings could be found and that
would be brought to the committee. The committee member from that department
would bring the information to the committee to present it and a decision will be made.
Two incentives for employees who present ideas are public recognition (possibly at a
Council meeting) and continued employment. There are a lot of cuts that could
potentially save a person from being laid off, etc. Whether an idea is approved or not,
employees should always be encouraged to continue looking at ways to save the City
money.
Frank Carr stated that it will be less costly as time goes on due to the fact that you
come to a point where there are no other sources of money saving ideas. He stated
that this idea is quantifiable and verifiable. His past employer ended up saving $75,000
in 9 months. That is a large amount of money although it looks small the grand
scheme of things.
Councilors discussed the potential committee with pros and cons for each. They are
intrigued but not sure if will cost more money with staff time or if it would be worth the
time. They will continue to look into this idea.
Councilor Nealley suggested Action Steps:
1. Starts as a pilot, 30 day pilot program
2. If Frank Carr has the time, would like him to be a part of the start the pilot
3. Committee report back to the committee chosen to head this, the progress of the
pilot program.
Representative from each department for the committee suggested by City Manager
Conlow.
Councilor Gallant stated that the City Manager will be tasked with looking into the
potential pilot program within the next 30 days and go from there.
4. Executive Session – 36 MRSA Section 841 (2) – Hardship Abatement
Councilor Sprague moved to go into executive session, Councilor Nealley seconded, so
approved.
5. Open Session – Hardship Abatement A Decision
Staff recommendation moved, seconded and approved.
Adjourned at 6:17pm.